Session 6: Research-based Interventions to Advance Comprehension

Research-based Interventions to Promote Fluency and Oral Language

 

Materials

 

Define Session Goals

  • Define vocabulary knowledge in terms of depth and breadth.
  • Identify effective methods to build vocabulary knowledge.
  • Identify methods for differentiating vocabulary instruction.
  • Explain how to identify target words for vocabulary instruction.
  • Define reading comprehension.
  • Explain the sociocultural perspective and relate the perspective to reading for meaning.
  • Explain what “good readers” do when they read text for understanding.
  • Identify effective methods to advance comprehension skills.
  • Identify methods for differentiating comprehension instruction.
  • Explain how to monitor progress of meaning-focused skills.

 

Explicit Vocabulary Instruction

  • Explain the importance of vocabulary knowledge to reading for meaning (slide 4).
  • Explain the importance of explicit and systematic vocabulary instruction.
    • Review how to explicitly teach vocabulary knowledge listed on slide 5.
    • Click on the video hyperlink (slide 5).
    • Watch the video of Vocabulary Instruction from the Meadows Center.
    • Ask participants to look for examples of the steps listed on slide 5 as they watch.
    • After the video, ask for examples of each bullet point listed on slide 5.
  • Explain the importance of teaching morphology (slide 6).
    • List the steps associated with teaching phonology listed on slide 6.
    • Click on the video hyperlink on slide 6 (IES Video 8: Morphology).
    • Ask participants to look for examples of explicit instruction in the video as they watch the video.
    • After the video ask...
      • How could we make this lesson more explicit?
      • How could you increase the number opportunities students have to encounter the words, prefixes, suffixes?
      • How would you provide affirmative and corrective feedback?
      • End with a discussion of how morphology also supports spelling and decoding.

 

Choosing What Words to Teach

  • Discuss how to select Words for Vocabulary Instruction (slides 7-10) using Beck’s Tiers of Words.
    • Share slide 7 and ask what words participants would teach.
    • Share slide 7 and explain why the target word was selected.
    • Click the video hyperlink on Slide 7 of the Reading Rockets interview with Dr. Isabel Beck.
    • After the video, move to slide 9 and 10 sharing examples of the relevance of tier 2 words and the difference between tier 1, tier 2 and tier 3 words.

 

Depth of Vocabulary Knowledge

  • Explain the importance of depth in vocabulary knowledge instruction by providing examples of different levels of knowledge on slide 11.
  • On slide 12, explain what it means to know a word.
  • On slide 13, share the example of using gradients to support understanding a word and a word’s relationships to other words.
    • Click on the hyperlink to the video.
      • Share the Reading Rockets Video of Using a Concept Sort in the Classroom.
      • Discuss how concepts also facilitate the understanding between words and concepts.
    • Share slides 14-15 to show other methods and ask participants how these tools could lead to depth of vocabulary knowledge.
  • Share slide 16 as a way for students to discuss level of word knowledge with students and also help students evaluate their own level of word knowledge.
    • Ask participants to complete the chart and raise their hands to identify their level of knowledge of the target terms listed.
      • Phonological awareness
      • Phonics
      • Phonemic awareness

 

Intensifying Vocabulary Instruction

  • Share handouts from the National Center on Intensive Intervention.
    • Example of planning to differentiate core instruction at tier 1, tier 3 and for students on alternate standards (slide 17).
    • Share the sample lesson plan (slide 18).
    • Ask people to discuss the questions on the slide and role play the sample script and procedures in groups of 3-4.
      • What is the target skill?
      • What makes this lesson explicit?
      • What example do you see related to transfer of the skill?
      • How could you make this more or less intensive based on learner need?
  • Share slide 19 of additional suggestions for intensifying vocabulary instruction.
    • Ask participants for their ideas.
    • Share suggestions for students with disabilities and limited verbal speech (slide 20).

 

Monitoring Vocabulary Progress

  • Review progress mentoring of vocabulary knowledge (slide 21).
    • Share the rating scale as a way to gauge level of knowledge.
    • Ask participants how they assess vocabulary knowledge.
      • Depth and breadth

 

Define Comprehension

  • Define reading comprehension (slide 23).
    • Reflect back to the Simple View of Reading and explain that it is dependent on several skills including effective word reading, higher order language processing (inference generation), and active engagement with the text.
    • Explain comprehension as a relationship between the reader, text and task (slides 24-26).
    • On slide 26, ask participants to explain what the reader has to do to understand the text.
      • Discuss inferences, word and their referents, vocabulary knowledge, homonyms, etc.
    • On slide 27, summarize by defining what effective comprehension.
    • On slide 28, explain reading instruction from a sociocultural perspective.

 

Research-Based Reading Comprehension Instruction

  • Explain that effective reading comprehension instruction teaches the skills that good readers do.
  • Review slide 29 of what good readers typically do.
  • Explain the components of good comprehension instruction (slide 30).
  • Explain the importance of strategy instruction and instruction that emphasizes building a mental model of text (slide 31).
  • Click on the hyperlink to the video.
    • Share the Turnaround Support video of Nell Duke explaining the importance of reading comprehension strategy instruction.
      • Discuss why this works – again these are the skills good readers use while reading.
  • Explain what effective comprehension instruction involves (slide 32).
    • Click on the video hyperlink.
      • Share the video of comprehension instruction in an classroom of ELLs.
      • Ask participants to write down what the lesson targets as they watch the video.
      • After the video, ask participants to get in groups of 3-4 and respond to the following:
        • How was comprehension addressed?
        • How was vocabulary addressed?
        • What are the strategies that specifically were helpful to ELLs?
        • What made this lesson explicit?
          • Discuss as a whole group.
          • Discuss the importance of being explicit.
          • Discuss the benefit of providing multiple examples.

 

Strategies that Support Comprehension

  • Knowledge of text structure (34-35)
    • Explain the importance of understanding text structure to comprehension (slide 34).
    • Explain that story grammar is necessary, but we also have to address that characters are not static and that perspectives also change while reading a narrative (slide 35).
  • The ability to generate inferences (slides 36-38)
    • Explain the importance of inference generation to understanding text (slide 37-38).
    • On slide 37, share the example and ask participants to explain why this would be an important inference to understanding.
    • Share the other example and ask the participants to identify the necessary inference and generate a question to support student inference making.
    • Explain the need to make the importance of inference generation explicit to students (slide 38).
      • Click the hyperlink to the video on Question-Answer Relationships.
      • After participants view the video, ask them to respond to the questions in groups of 3-4.
      • Review responses as a whole group.
        • Stress the question types that reflect an inference.
        • Explain the importance of thinking aloud when giving corrective feedback.
  • Comprehension strategy instruction (slides 39-42)
    • Explain the importance of comprehension strategies (slide 40).
    • Share an example (slide 40).
      • Click on the video hyperlink.
      • Share the video on reciprocal teaching from Reading Rockets.
      • As participants watch, ask them to identify the target strategies.
      • After watching the video, ask participants to respond to the questions on the slide.
      • Ask a whole group review responses.
        • Explain the importance of modeling corrective feedback by explicitly thinking aloud each step of the strategy.
    • Share another example (Slide 41).
      • Review the paragraph shrinking strategy from Peer Assisted Learning Strategies.
      • Click on the hyperlink to the video of paragraph shrinking from the IRIS module.
      • After watching the video, ask participants to respond to the questions.
      • As a whole group discuss responses.
        • Ask about peer tutoring as another opportunity for students to apply a comprehension skill taught.

 

Intensifying Comprehension Instruction

  • Share handouts from the National Center on Intensive Intervention.
    • Example of planning to differentiate core instruction at tier 1, tier 3 and for students on alternate standards (slide 43).
    • Share the sample lesson plan (slide 44).
    • Ask people to discuss the questions on the slide and role play the sample script and procedures in groups of 3-4.
      • What is the target skill?
      • What makes this lesson explicit?
      • What example do you see related to transfer of the skill?
      • How could you make this more or less intensive based on learner need?
  • Share slide 45 of additional suggestions for intensifying comprehension instruction.
    • Ask participants for their ideas.
    • Share additional suggestions.
      • Making visual cue cards (slide 46).
    • Share additional strategies for students with disabilities and limited speech.
      • Sample curriculum (Early Literacy Skill Builder; Friends on the Block; slide 48-49).
      • Graphic organizers that include visual supports (slide 50).
      • Visual question cards with scripts.

 

Monitoring Comprehension Progress

  • Review progress mentoring of vocabulary knowledge (slide 21).
    • Share the rating scale as a way to gauge level of knowledge.
    • Ask participants how they assess comprehension.
      • Refer back to competency 3.

 

Case Study: Juan

  • Provide the case study of Juan.
  • Ask participants to read the case in groups of 3-4.
  • After participants to respond to questions 1 & 2 and stopping.
  • After participants respond to questions 1 & 2, review responses as a whole group.
    • Discuss word identification (multisyllabic words, fluency) and comprehension difficulties (longer texts, more complex concepts).
    • Discuss supports that Juan has in addition to his recent admission that he is losing interest in reading.
  • Ask participants to return to their groups and respond to questions 3-5.
    • Have participants share their responses.
      • Make sure progress monitoring is targeting the needed skills (multisyllabic words, fluency, comprehension.
      • Make sure the instructional practices are those that are based in evidence.
      • Stress the need for explicit instruction to decrease Juan’s frustration.

 

Review Culminating Project

  • Ask participants to get in groups of 3 to 4 and share their final reflections.
    • Ask as a whole group, how they used data to inform their instruction.
    • How did the students respond to instruction?
    • What they would do differently?
    • What burning questions remain?